‘The Great British Baking Show’s Semifinals Are Pâtisserie Cubed
Let’s see who pulls themselves together and who goes around the horn.
The Great British Baking Show Season 11 semi-finals have arrived, and unlike other seasons, the Top 4 is a motley crew. In other seasons, firm favorites have emerged by this point: Nancy, Nadiya, Candice, and Rahul all spring to mind. But this season is less easy to parse. There’s Hermine, who is very good at traditional cakes but can’t function outside that lane. Laura somehow manages to pull beautiful bakes out of her backside at the last minute, even as she’s falling apart. Peter is a judge’s favorite, but he’s faltered the previous few weeks. Then there’s Dave, so forgettable I never remember he’s still here.
Pâtisserie solidified itself as Baking Show’s semi-final subject very early on, starting with the never-aired stateside Season 2. (Season 1 didn’t have a semi-final since the format was so different.) The only year pâtisserie wasn’t the semi since then was in Season 6 (PBS Season 3), when it was the quarterfinal, leaving “Chocolate Week” as the penultimate round. It’s a round that gives the show a chance to revisit things that failed the first time (like meringue and choux pastry), tackle difficult biscuits and cakes (madeleines and opera cakes), and sometimes do downright weird stuff that doesn’t go anywhere else. (Think fondant fancies, petits fours, and entremets.)