‘Ludwig’ Returns for Musical Chairs in the Season 2 Premiere
"I don’t think mummy ever sat in a chair she didn’t complain about."
The BBC’s quirky detective series Ludwig, starring David Mitchell in the title role, has finally returned for Season 2. The first season introduced John “Ludwig” Taylor, an eccentric loner and puzzle-maker, when his sister-in-law, Lucy Betts-Taylor (Anna Maxwell Martin), called and asked him to find his identical twin brother, Detective James Taylor (also played by Mitchell). When John dropped by the Cambridge police station to see if he could find anything useful on his brother’s desk, the inevitable happened: his brother’s colleagues mistook him for James and sent him out on a case. His brother’s new partner, DI Russell Carter (Dipo Ola), took DI Taylor’s frequent blunders and eccentricities in stride, along with his appalling driving and general weirdness.
Thanks to his genius with puzzles (“Ludwig” is his professional name, and also Beethoven’s first name, whose cleverly edited top tunes form the series soundtrack), John maintained an outstanding, if eccentric, solve record. However, the finale revealed John’s identity, letting the Cambridge police save themselves some embarrassment (and maintain their exceptional solve rate) by offering him a consultancy.
But let’s get to Season 2’s first murder! It takes place at Cambridge’s Theatre Royal, just before the curtain rises on a performance of a musical, Song of Solomon. Hannah Foster (Bairavi Manoharan), assistant to local MP Joanne Kemper (Sian Clifford), drops by with her employer’s opera glasses. In the opposite box, patrician matron Lilibeth Lowery (Gillian Royale), accompanied by her two bickering daughters, Portia (Doon Mackichan) and Patricia (Rebecca Front), take their seats, squabbling and complaining loudly. Lilibeth’s seat tips her almost backward, giving her yet another opportunity to complain. The camera cuts to a fancy split-screen of the theater interior, but as the show begins and the lights dim, Joanne tells Hanna to call her car, and also the Cambridge Police, and specifically ask for Ziegler. Lilibeth Lowery is dead, stabbed with a pair of scissors, and the two sisters scream.
The next morning, Lucy, James’s wife, replays the last voicemail she received from him, in which he says he’s desperate to escape his marriage. The Taylors have a history of disappearing fathers; John and James’s father left his family suddenly, with no explanation. Her son, Henry (Dylan Hughes), claims his father is lying to protect them, but Lucy is unconvinced. After eating Henry’s breakfast, John works on his “piles,” the information from James’s (stolen) files. He’s convinced that as he sifts through pages of data, he’ll find something significant.
A call from the station interrupts him; Lucy drives him to the parking lot to meet Russell, and explains he realized his driver’s license expired during COVID. (That should solve the terrible driving issue.) Inside, DCS Carol Shaw (Dorothy Atkinson) tells him that former colleagues DC Simon Evans (Gerran Howell) and DS Alice Finch (Izuka Hoyle) have been transferred due to the events of Season 1; they are meeting new colleagues DC Ethan Cole (Ben Ashenden) and DC Caitlin Sullivan (Rumi Sutton) at the theater. Above all, she tells him to avoid interacting with her superior, Chief Constable Ziegler (Ralph Ineson), as much as possible, since he doesn’t know John was impersonating James for all that time, and orders Russell never to let Ziegler and John alone together. Russell has to remind John he is no longer impersonating his brother; technically, he’s new and has only just met everyone.
When they arrive at the theater, there are a couple of problems: both sisters have confessed, but there’s only one stab wound. (So who didn’t commit the crime?) In one of the funniest scenes so far, both women admit they hated their mother for decades. Patricia all but says she thinks her mother killed her husband (“I’m not necessarily blaming her”) and then refused to let her have a dog. She also wouldn’t let former beauty queen Portia meet up with her ex-husband. Again, both sisters claim they committed the murder.
Left to her own devices, Lucy visits the East Anglian Advertiser offices, which, as its name suggests, is mostly ads with one crime story in the current edition (“Shop Burgled”). She introduces herself to the editor, Gareth Fisher (Mark Bonnar), as an experienced freelance photojournalist, and tempts him with a photograph of a celebrity committing adultery, borrowed from John’s piles. But he insists his paper covers only local news, not crime. As he ushers her to the door, Lucy mentions she is married to a detective and is sister-in-law to a consultant, Ludwig. Apparently, Gareth is a big fan of Ludwig’s puzzles, so she promises him Ludwig will create a couple of puzzles per week for the paper, and is handed a crime reporter’s badge.
Lucy uses her badge to gain access to Adam Newsum (Josh Bolt), Holly Pinder’s conspirator and murderer, who is in prison. He says he knows nothing about Holly’s activities and he’s already talked to DI Russell Carter, despite the team being officially warned not to get involved. Adam is convinced that neither Russell nor Lucy know what they’re looking for.
At the station, the team gloomily examines the evidence board. The murder scissors were in the mother’s purse, but John explains it’s all useless since the sisters have both confessed. Ziegler arrives to check on their progress, and Ethan reveals he found a ticket stub in the opposite box, which had been occupied, and suggests they contact the box office to find out who bought it. Ziegler tells them it won’t be necessary, as he spoke to the witness, MP Joanne Kemper, who didn’t see anything, and whose name Ziegler insists must be kept out of all reports. He then asks John to go with him to interview her, to Russell’s dismay.
Ziegler explains that his family’s connections with Joanne’s make her particularly vulnerable to outside threats, which is why she is not officially a witness to the murder. Another police bigshot, Detective Chief Constable Ronan Radley (Michael Wildman), who liaises with the Met’s Specialist Protection Unit, also attends Kemper’s interview, where she admits her attention was drawn to the opposite box because someone was waving a phone around as the show was about to start, and she’s a stickler for correct etiquette at the theater.
Kemper’s adoring assistant, Hannah Foster, takes up the narrative because she saw the two daughters’ reactions: they jumped up and screamed. But the sisters were never alone in the box after that. John is particularly pleased that the two women were kept separate as they each confessed and were arrested. He’s even more enthused to escape Ziegler’s car on the drive back, heading to the theater. (Unfortunately, this means Russell has to report to Shaw that John escaped from Ziegler, and she isn’t happy about it.)
Upon arriving, he’s distracted by the center chair in the box where the murdered woman died. When Russell calls, John asks him to bring the two sisters to the theater because he’s ready to extract a confession.
(Why the theater? He can’t interview the sisters at the station because he has no car, he doesn’t know how to get from the theater to the station, and his phone’s battery is dying. That’s Ludwig for you.)
The team escorts the two sisters, wearing pearls with their jailhouse sweats, to the theatre, where John takes the stage. “This was no murder. It was an accident,” John declares. The chair Mrs. Lowery sat in needed repairs; didn’t she mention that? The daughters laugh; their mother complained about every chair she ever sat in.
However, this time her complaints were correct: the chair she was sitting in killed her. Lilibeth tipped back in the chair next to her; when the lights went down, she tried to pull it upright and sit up. That caused more vital bits of hardware on the seat to snap off, and Lilibeth lurched forward, and the pair of scissors Patricia had in her purse were forced into her mother’s chest, killing her, a one-in-a-million accident. It’s improbable, John says, but clearly it was possible. As Patricia is led back to the police car, the press (aka Lucy) is already there to capture the moment.
Shaw calls John into her office to pass on Ziegler’s congratulations, offer her own, and add another reminder to keep out of his way in future. Ziegler is apparently very interested in talking to James. Meanwhile, John has piles of paper, as the camera pans down to the off-limits station basement, where computers hold secrets.
Ludwig Season 2 continues with new episodes on Tuesdays through mid-November 2026. All six episodes are already available to stream for BritBox Premier subscribers.
Ludwig
Season 1 is available to stream for all BritBox subscribers. Ludwig Season 3 is already in production and expected to debut in 2027.
First one’s free, kids! Upgrade to a paid subscription today for our full coverage of BritBox shows.
